Best 7 Cake Shops in Brooklyn

Brooklyn, a vibrant hub of creativity and culture, is also home to some of the finest cake shops you’ll ever find. Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, planning a wedding, or simply craving something sweet, our guide to the Best 7 Cake Shops in Brooklyn will help you discover the most delightful confections the borough has to offer. From classic flavors to innovative designs, these bakeries provide a sweet escape for every occasion.

When choosing the perfect cake shop, consider the following services and aspects:

Custom Cake Design: Personalize your cake with unique designs and themes.
Flavor Variety: Explore a range of flavors, from traditional vanilla and chocolate to exotic options like matcha or passion fruit.
Cake Tasting: Schedule tastings to ensure the flavors meet your expectations.
Dietary Options: Find options for vegan, gluten-free, or allergen-friendly cakes.
Delivery Services: Convenient cake delivery within Brooklyn for stress-free celebrations.
Price Range: Consider your budget, with prices typically ranging from $20 to $200 depending on size and customization.
Customer Reviews: Check reviews for feedback on taste and service quality.

Discovering the perfect cake shop in Brooklyn is an adventure in flavor and creativity. Delve into our list and let your taste buds explore the sweetest side of the borough.

1. Rimini Pastry Shoppe
2. Mille-Feuille Bakery Cafe
3. Tasty Pastry Shoppe

4. Michael's Pastry Shop
5. Patisserie Tomoko
6. Charlotte Patisserie
7. Buttermilk Bakeshop

Number of companies

4441

Verified reviews

4,59

Average rating

(718)2360644

1. Rimini Pastry Shoppe

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

6822 Bay Pkwy, 11204.0, Brooklyn

Bakery

Why we chose them

Rimini Pastry Shoppe has been a cherished destination for Italian dessert enthusiasts since 1973. Located in the heart of Brooklyn, this family-owned bakery has built a legacy on the art of Italian pastry making, brought to life by founder John Zito. John’s dedication to quality is evident in every handcrafted item, from custom fondant cakes to traditional Italian pastries. The bakery prides itself on using only the finest ingredients, with all products made from scratch, free of artificial additives, preservatives, and trans fats. This commitment to excellence has made it a landmark for customers traveling from across New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut.

The bakery offers a diverse array of services, specializing in cakes for weddings, birthdays, and holidays, as well as a variety of Italian and French breads baked on-premise. Their selection of cookies, including popular choices like seven-layer, macaroons, and biscotti, highlights the blend of tradition and current trends. With over four decades of experience, Rimini’s dedication to quality and reasonable pricing ensures customer satisfaction. This dedication, combined with a rich history and passion for authentic Italian flavors, makes it a standout addition to our company directory.

2. Mille-Feuille Bakery Cafe

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,7/5

622 Vanderbilt Ave, 11238.0, Brooklyn

Patisserie

Why we chose them

Mille-Feuille Bakery Cafe, a traditional French bakery, has been delighting customers since 2011 with its authentic pastries crafted by Chef Olivier Dessyn and his wife. Renowned for bringing the essence of Paris to the heart of Brooklyn, the bakery offers a delectable array of viennoiseries and pâtisseries. The cafe has gained a loyal following due to its exquisite offerings and charming atmosphere, making it a must-visit destination for pastry lovers.

After the success of their initial locations, the founders expanded to Brooklyn in 2020, where they quickly became a beloved fixture in the community. Patrons are treated to a delightful selection of classic French sweets, making it the closest experience to Parisian indulgence without leaving the city. This dedication to quality and authenticity is why the bakery has earned a prominent spot in our company directory.

(718)8339493

3. Tasty Pastry Shoppe

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,7/5

8216-18 13th Ave, 11228.0, Brooklyn

Bakery

Why we chose them

Tasty Pastry Shoppe is a delightful haven for those seeking authentic Italian sweet treats and customized cakes. Renowned for its exquisite range of specialty cakes, including wedding cakes and a diverse selection of theme cakes such as princess, superhero, and seasonal holiday cakes, the shop has become a favorite in Brooklyn. Emphasizing freshness and quality, their team of Italian Culinary Chefs combines traditional recipes with modern flair, creating a menu that caters to all tastes. From sugar-free and gluten-free options to vibrant custom creations, their offerings promise to dazzle every palate.

With an extensive range of baked goods, this bakery stands out for its largest selection of sugar-free treats in Brooklyn, offering everything from cookies and pastries to cupcakes and chocolate delights. The passion for baking is evident in their dedication to using the finest and freshest ingredients, ensuring each product meets the highest standards of taste and quality. Their commitment to creating delicious treats for everyone, regardless of dietary needs, has earned them the accolade of “Pastries Worth Traveling For.” Whether you’re in search of a show-stopping custom cake or simply indulging in a sweet craving, this shop is a must-visit destination.

(718)3769200

4. Michael's Pastry Shop

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,6/5

2923 Avenue R #49, 11229.0, Brooklyn

Bakery

Why we chose them

Michael’s Pastry Shop is a beloved Italian bakery known for its exquisite cakes and a wide array of other sweet treats. Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, NY, this bakery has become a local favorite for those seeking authentic Italian confections. With a focus on quality and tradition, the shop offers an enticing selection of baked goods that delight both the eyes and the taste buds. Customers can easily order cookies and other specialties through their convenient online platform, making it a go-to spot for anyone craving a touch of Italy.

In addition to its mouthwatering offerings, the bakery is recognized for its inviting atmosphere and commitment to customer satisfaction. The shop’s online presence, powered by BentoBox, ensures that patrons have easy access to their services and updates. Whether you’re planning a celebration or simply indulging in a sweet treat, this bakery provides an exceptional experience that captures the essence of Italian baking. Their dedication to excellence is evident in every bite, making them a standout choice for our company directory.

(718)3887121

5. Patisserie Tomoko

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

568 Union Ave, 11211.0, Brooklyn

Patisserie
Dessert restaurant
Japanese confectionery shop

Why we chose them

Patisserie Tomoko stands out in Williamsburg, New York, by elegantly merging French and European pastry traditions with a distinctive Japanese twist. This unique patisserie offers a captivating culinary experience, featuring an exotic open-space design that includes both a Dessert Bar and a Take Out counter. The Dessert Bar presents a delightful three-course dessert flight, which can be expertly paired with wine or sake, creating a memorable dining experience for guests. At the Take Out counter, visitors can indulge in original pastries and baked goods crafted by the renowned Chef Tomoko, making this destination a must-visit for dessert aficionados.

Offering a blend of patisserie, dessert restaurant, and Japanese confectionery shop, this establishment highlights the art of fusion cuisine. The menu is a testament to creativity and skill, showcasing the harmonious blend of flavors that define its offerings. Nationwide shipping ensures that even those outside New York can savor these exquisite creations. This innovative approach to desserts, combined with its unique ambiance, makes it a noteworthy addition to our directory, celebrating both tradition and innovation in the world of pastry.

(718)3838313

6. Charlotte Patisserie

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,6/5

596 Manhattan Ave, 11222.0, Brooklyn

Patisserie
Bakery
Coffee shop

Why we chose them

Welcome to the House of the Elegant Dessert, where culinary artistry meets French café charm. Specializing in delectable patisserie, bakery delights, and a cozy coffee shop experience, this establishment is renowned for its exquisite creations. The signature Raspberry – Crème Brûlée Cake and the classic Cloud Cake, featuring mascarpone mousse and seasonal berries, are just a glimpse into the diverse menu. Known for its brunch offerings, including the oat latte and gut-healthy sourdough, this patisserie has become a cherished destination for both locals and visitors seeking a taste of heaven.

With a commitment to quality and elegance, the patisserie offers more than just desserts. From its tempting plum tart to the symphony of flavors found in the Duet cake, the options are endless. The café also provides a delightful environment for social gatherings, even featuring a backyard space to enjoy European soccer games. Whether celebrating special occasions like Mother’s Day or simply indulging in a morning coffee with a matcha latte, this patisserie promises a unique and memorable culinary experience.

(347)9873941

7. Buttermilk Bakeshop

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

264 5th Ave, 11215.0, Brooklyn

Bakery
Cake shop

Why we chose them

Buttermilk Bakeshop stands out for its delightful selection of made-to-order desserts, creating an inviting atmosphere for anyone with a sweet tooth. Known for its cozy surrounds, this bakery offers a personalized touch to every creation, ensuring that each dessert is as unique as the occasion it celebrates. The dedication to quality ingredients and attention to detail make it a cherished spot for those seeking exceptional baked goods.

The bakery and cake shop services provide a wide range of options, from classic confections to innovative new flavors, catering to diverse tastes and preferences. This commitment to excellence and creativity is why we have chosen this company for our directory. Whether it’s a special celebration or simply a craving for something sweet, their offerings promise to delight and satisfy.

FAQs

What services do cake shops in Brooklyn typically offer?

Cake shops in Brooklyn often offer custom cake design, a variety of flavors, dietary options such as vegan or gluten-free cakes, cake tastings, and delivery services.

How much does a custom cake in Brooklyn usually cost?

The cost of a custom cake in Brooklyn can range from €18 to €180, depending on size, design complexity, and customization.

How far in advance should I order a custom cake from a Brooklyn cake shop?

It's recommended to order a custom cake at least 2-4 weeks in advance, especially for larger events like weddings, to ensure availability and ample time for design.

What should I consider when choosing a cake shop in Brooklyn?

Consider factors such as custom design options, flavor variety, dietary accommodations, customer reviews, delivery services, and your budget.

Do Brooklyn cake shops offer cake tastings?

Yes, many cake shops in Brooklyn offer cake tastings, allowing you to sample different flavors and ensure they meet your expectations.

Are there vegan or gluten-free options available at Brooklyn cake shops?

Many cake shops in Brooklyn provide vegan and gluten-free options to accommodate dietary needs, ensuring everyone can enjoy a delicious cake.

Can I get a cake delivered within Brooklyn?

Yes, most cake shops offer delivery services within Brooklyn, making it convenient to receive your cake without the hassle of pickup.

How do I find reviews for cake shops in Brooklyn?

You can find customer reviews for Brooklyn cake shops on platforms like Google, Yelp, or social media, providing insights into taste and service quality.