The 7 Best New American Restaurants in Brooklyn

Brooklyn’s culinary scene is a vibrant tapestry, where diverse flavors and innovative techniques come together to create something truly special. Among the myriad dining options, New American restaurants stand out for their creative takes on traditional American dishes, often incorporating global influences. This guide explores the 7 best New American restaurants in Brooklyn, where you can experience a symphony of flavors and textures that redefine what it means to eat American cuisine.

As you explore these culinary gems, consider the following services and aspects that define a remarkable New American dining experience:

Seasonal Menus: Emphasizing fresh, locally-sourced ingredients that change with the seasons.
Innovative Dishes: Unique twists on classic American recipes, often with international influences.
Craft Cocktails: A selection of artisanal drinks that complement the menu.
Farm-to-Table Philosophy: Commitment to sustainability and support of local farmers.
Artistic Presentation: Dishes that are as visually stunning as they are delicious.
Casual Elegance: A relaxed atmosphere with a touch of sophistication.
Price Range: Options that cater to various budgets, with meals typically ranging from $15 to $40.
Brunch Offerings: A popular choice for weekend dining, featuring creative takes on breakfast and lunch dishes.

Embark on a culinary journey through Brooklyn’s best New American restaurants, where tradition meets innovation on every plate.

1. Diner
2. Otway
3. Iris Café

4. Bushwick Burger Co
5. Estuary at One°15 Brooklyn Marina
6. Dinner Party
7. Lori Jayne

Number of companies

2305

Verified reviews

4,37

Average rating

(718)4863077

1. Diner

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,3/5

85 Broadway, 11249.0, Brooklyn

American restaurant
Bar
Brunch restaurant
Hamburger restaurant
New American restaurant
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Diner is a unique culinary experience located in South Williamsburg, Brooklyn. Set in a charming converted dining car, this establishment blends nostalgia with modern culinary trends, offering an authentic taste of American cuisine. Known for its versatility, it serves as an American restaurant, bar, and brunch restaurant, catering to a wide range of tastes. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic hamburger or exploring new American dishes, this place provides a welcoming atmosphere for all occasions.

With a focus on quality and sustainability, the restaurant prides itself on its “Know Your Farmers” initiative, highlighting its commitment to sourcing fresh, local ingredients. This dedication extends to their catering services, ensuring that every event is both delicious and memorable. Patrons can also enjoy a seamless dining experience with convenient features like reservations and gift cards. Diner is a delightful spot that combines the charm of a bygone era with the vibrant culinary spirit of Brooklyn, making it a noteworthy addition to our directory.

(917)9091889

2. Otway

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

930 Fulton St, 11238.0, Brooklyn

New American restaurant
Bar
Brunch restaurant
Wine bar

Why we chose them

Otway is a standout destination for those seeking a fresh take on American bistro cuisine. Known for its inviting atmosphere and expertly crafted dishes, this New American restaurant offers a diverse menu that caters to a wide range of tastes. Guests can indulge in a delightful brunch or savor a thoughtfully curated dinner, all while enjoying a selection of wines from their impressive wine bar. The restaurant’s commitment to quality and creativity makes it a must-visit spot for both locals and visitors.

Beyond its culinary offerings, Otway provides a welcoming bar environment, perfect for socializing and enjoying crafted cocktails or a fine glass of wine. The establishment also accommodates large parties, ensuring a memorable experience for gatherings of any size. With options to order online and purchase gift certificates, this bistro caters to both dine-in and take-out preferences. Its dedication to accessibility and customer satisfaction highlights why this restaurant is an excellent choice for inclusion in our directory.

(718)9242362

3. Iris Café

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,1/5

125 Bridge Park Dr, 11201.0, Brooklyn

Restaurant
Bar
Brunch restaurant
Cafe
Cocktail bar
Coffee shop
New American restaurant

Why we chose them

Iris Café is a hip and inviting spot nestled in the charming cobblestone streets of Willowtown, Brooklyn Heights. Established in 2009 by Brooklyn-raised brothers, this hidden gem has become a beloved destination for locals and visitors alike. Offering a delightful blend of a restaurant, cafe, and bar, it serves a Nouveau American-inspired menu that seamlessly marries high-dining flair with the casual elegance of a bistro. The cozy yet sophisticated atmosphere makes it a perfect choice for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, whether you’re looking to enjoy a leisurely meal or a quick coffee break.

Known for its versatility, Iris Café doubles as a brunch restaurant and cocktail bar, making it an ideal spot for any occasion. The thoughtfully crafted menu and warm ambiance create a unique dining experience that captures the essence of New York’s vibrant culinary scene. With services ranging from dine-in to carryout and delivery, this establishment caters to a variety of tastes and preferences, ensuring that each visit is memorable and satisfying. Its reputation as a hidden treasure in the heart of Brooklyn makes it a standout addition to our directory.

(718)9750224

4. Bushwick Burger Co

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

354 Cornelia St, 11237.0, Brooklyn

American restaurant
Hamburger restaurant
New American restaurant

Why we chose them

Bushwick Burger Co. is a quirky burger joint that has become a beloved spot for the Brooklyn community, offering a delightful blend of classic and New American flavors. Known for its inviting outdoor seating, this restaurant provides a unique dining experience that combines the charm of a local eatery with the quality of a gourmet burger establishment. Patrons rave about their double cheeseburgers, bacon cheeseburgers, fries, tots, and chicken tenders, all of which are crafted with care and a nod to familiar favorites like Shake Shack. The restaurant proudly serves delicious food that might seem a bit pricey to some, but many agree that the taste and quality justify the cost.

As an American restaurant, Hamburger restaurant, and New American restaurant, Bushwick Burger Co. stands out for its solid menu offerings and convenient delivery service, though some reviews suggest the latter can be hit or miss. The establishment’s commitment to providing great classic flavors, as highlighted in customer testimonials, makes it a must-visit destination for both locals and visitors alike. With an easy-to-navigate website where customers can explore the menu and order online, the restaurant ensures that everyone has access to their mouth-watering creations at their convenience.

(718)5216744

5. Estuary at One°15 Brooklyn Marina

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,1/5

159 Bridge Park Dr, 11201.0, Brooklyn

New American restaurant

Why we chose them

Estuary at ONE°15 Brooklyn Marina stands out in our directory for its unique blend of fine dining and stunning waterfront views. Nestled in the picturesque Brooklyn Bridge Park, this New American restaurant offers a relaxed atmosphere where expertly prepared dishes take center stage. Drawing inspiration from its prime location, the bistro features a menu that showcases fresh seafood, meats, and vegetables, emphasizing simplicity, accessibility, and quality. Diners can enjoy a variety of seasonal salads and globally influenced fare, making it a perfect destination for those seeking diverse culinary experiences.

The appeal of this waterfront bistro extends beyond its delectable menu to its vibrant setting. With a focus on providing “Food for Every Mood,” the restaurant ensures that each visit is memorable and satisfying. The expertly crafted dishes reflect a commitment to quality ingredients and thoughtful preparation, making it a noteworthy addition to our directory. Its dedication to delivering fine American fare in a stunning location is what makes it a must-visit destination for both locals and visitors alike.

(347)4639173

6. Dinner Party

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

274 Hall St, 11205.0, Brooklyn

New American restaurant

Why we chose them

Dinner Party is an intimate and cozy New American restaurant in Brooklyn, offering a unique dining experience with its rotating menu of seasonal French and Californian-inspired cuisine. Founded in 2021 by six young women, this charming establishment quickly became a haven for food enthusiasts seeking a sense of community. The restaurant’s atmosphere is designed to feel like you’re dining among friends, whether you’re seated with strangers or alongside your own group. Each night promises a delightful blend of rustic, lovingly-crafted dishes that balance tradition and creativity, making every visit a memorable culinary adventure.

In November 2024, Dinner Party is set to reopen at a larger space on 274 Hall Street, allowing them to welcome more guests each evening. The new location will maintain its beloved communal dining style, introducing additional walk-in bar seats and private tables for a more personalized experience. Despite the expansion, the restaurant remains dedicated to its core values of good food and good company. Guests can look forward to a rotating prix fixe menu that changes weekly, ensuring a fresh and exciting dining experience each time. The restaurant also offers gift cards, perfect for treating loved ones to a special night out. Sign up for weekly menu updates to stay connected with the vibrant kitchen gossip.

7. Lori Jayne

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,8/5

INSIDE ALPHAVILLE, 140 Wilson Ave, 11237.0, Brooklyn

Fried chicken takeaway
American restaurant
New American restaurant

Why we chose them

Lori Jayne is renowned for its “damn good nugs and fries,” offering a delightful mix of dine-in and takeaway options that have captivated food lovers. As an American restaurant with a modern twist, it stands out for its creative take on traditional favorites, serving up dishes that are both comforting and innovative. Their commitment to quality and flavor has made it a must-visit spot for anyone craving a satisfying meal.

This establishment excels in delivering a unique dining experience, with a menu that boasts a variety of tasty offerings. Whether you’re in the mood for crispy fried chicken takeaway or exploring the inventive dishes of a New American restaurant, you’ll find something to delight your taste buds. The combination of quality food and a welcoming atmosphere makes it a perfect addition to our directory, highlighting its role as a culinary gem in the area.

FAQs

What is a New American restaurant?

A New American restaurant offers creative takes on traditional American dishes, often incorporating global influences and using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients.

What services can I expect at a New American restaurant in Brooklyn?

You can expect seasonal menus, innovative dishes, craft cocktails, a farm-to-table philosophy, artistic presentation, and a casual yet elegant atmosphere.

What is the average price range for a meal at a New American restaurant in Brooklyn?

Meals typically range from €14 to €37, depending on the restaurant and the dishes ordered.

How do I choose a good New American restaurant in Brooklyn?

Consider factors such as the restaurant's emphasis on seasonal and locally-sourced ingredients, the creativity of their menu, customer reviews, ambiance, and price range.

Are reservations required at New American restaurants in Brooklyn?

While not always required, reservations are recommended, especially during peak dining hours or weekends, to ensure a table.

Do New American restaurants in Brooklyn offer brunch options?

Yes, many New American restaurants in Brooklyn offer brunch, featuring creative takes on breakfast and lunch dishes.

What should I consider when dining at a New American restaurant?

Consider the freshness of ingredients, the uniqueness of the menu, the skill in presentation, and the overall dining experience, including service and ambiance.

Do New American restaurants in Brooklyn accommodate dietary restrictions?

Many New American restaurants offer options for various dietary restrictions, but it's best to check with the restaurant in advance or inquire with the staff upon arrival.