The 7 Best Polish Restaurants in Brooklyn

Brooklyn is a melting pot of cultures and flavors, and its culinary scene reflects this vibrant diversity. Among the myriad of dining options, Polish restaurants hold a special place, offering hearty dishes that bring the taste of Eastern Europe to New York. In this guide, we will explore the 7 best Polish restaurants in Brooklyn, each offering a unique blend of traditional and modern Polish cuisine.

When considering where to dine, there are several aspects and services you might find appealing in a Polish restaurant:

Authentic Polish Dishes: Look for menus featuring classics like pierogi, kielbasa, and bigos.
Cozy Atmosphere: Many Polish eateries offer a warm, welcoming environment reminiscent of a traditional Polish home.
Family-Friendly Options: Many establishments provide meals suitable for all ages, making them perfect for family outings.
Vegetarian and Vegan Selections: While Polish cuisine is often meat-heavy, many places are now offering plant-based alternatives.
Reasonable Pricing: Expect to find hearty meals that offer great value, typically ranging from $10 to $30 per person.
Takeout and Delivery Services: Enjoy Polish cuisine from the comfort of your home with convenient takeaway options.
Event Catering: Some restaurants offer catering services for events, bringing the flavors of Poland to your celebrations.

Explore the rich tapestry of flavors and experiences that these Polish restaurants offer, and discover why they are a beloved part of Brooklyn’s dining landscape.

1. Karczma
2. Pierozek
3. Christina's

4. Polonica Restaurant
5. Restaurant Relax
6. Jw Real Polish Delicatessen
7. Polish & Slavic Center Cafeteria

Number of companies

4111

Verified reviews

4,61

Average rating

(718)3491744

1. Karczma

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,6/5

136 Greenpoint Ave, 11222.0, Brooklyn

Polish restaurant

Why we chose them

Karczma stands out in our directory for its dedication to offering an authentic Polish dining experience in the heart of Greenpoint. Known for its rustic farmhouse ambiance, the restaurant serves as a welcoming spot where guests are treated like family. Patrons can enjoy a variety of traditional Polish dishes, with the popular pierogi being a must-try. The atmosphere is further enhanced by waitresses in traditional dresses and the soothing sounds of Polish music, creating a unique cultural experience that transports diners straight to Poland.

Beyond its inviting indoor dining area, Karczma also offers outdoor seating, pick-up, and local delivery services, making it accessible to a wide range of customers. With a history of 15 years serving the community, it has become a beloved gathering place where people come not just for the food, but also for the camaraderie and sense of belonging. The restaurant’s commitment to quality service and authentic cuisine makes it a noteworthy addition to our directory, providing a rich taste of Poland in the bustling city of Brooklyn.

(718)5763866

2. Pierozek

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,8/5

592 Manhattan Ave, 11222.0, Brooklyn

Polish restaurant

Why we chose them

Pierozek stands out in the heart of Greenpoint, Brooklyn, known as “Little Poland,” offering an authentic Polish culinary experience. Specializing in handmade pierogi, this eatery presents a delightful array of traditional and modern flavors. From classic Ruskie (Potato & Cheese) and Sauerkraut & Mushroom to innovative options like Jalapeño and Murray’s Cheese Pierogi, the menu caters to both purists and adventurers. Complementing these dumplings, guests can savor other Polish delicacies such as Red Borscht, Croquettes, and Gołąbki (Stuffed Cabbage). The restaurant’s decor pays homage to the Polish Folk Art movement of the 1960s and 70s, with art and ceramics displayed on exposed brick and white marble, creating a cozy yet sophisticated atmosphere.

With a team of skilled, all-women pierogi-makers from Poland, Pierozek prides itself on its authentic culinary techniques passed down through generations. Approximately 2,000 pierogi are crafted daily, ensuring both quality and freshness. The restaurant’s commitment to preserving traditional recipes, alongside a modern twist, is a testament to its success. It offers both indoor and outdoor dining, allowing patrons to enjoy their meal in a setting that beautifully merges the past and present. This dedication to authenticity and quality makes Pierozek a standout addition to our directory, providing a genuine taste of Poland in New York.

(718)3834382

3. Christina's

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

853 Manhattan Ave, 11222.0, Brooklyn

Polish restaurant
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Christina’s stands out in the culinary landscape with its authentic Polish offerings, making it a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts. Known for its delectable Pierogi & other Polish favorites, this restaurant captures the essence of traditional Polish cuisine, providing a rich and flavorful dining experience. With a welcoming ambiance, it offers both a standard menu and a specialized breakfast menu, ensuring there’s something for everyone. The restaurant also enhances the dining atmosphere with Live Jazz Sessions every Sunday from 6-9 PM, creating an unforgettable experience for guests.

The establishment prides itself on being a true “House of Tastes,” inviting patrons to explore its culinary delights. For those looking to enjoy their meals at home, the restaurant provides a convenient Order Online service. As an added treat, customers can enjoy a Free Mimosa Drink with Breakfast Order, adding a touch of celebration to their morning routine. The restaurant’s commitment to quality and customer satisfaction is evident in every aspect, making it a standout choice in our directory for those seeking genuine Polish flavors.

(718)6305805

4. Polonica Restaurant

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

8303 3rd Ave, 11209.0, Brooklyn

Polish restaurant
Delivery Restaurant
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Polonica Restaurant is a cherished family-run establishment in Brooklyn, known for its authentic Polish-American cuisine. Established in 1991, this casual eatery has been delighting the community with over 60 years of family tradition in its recipes. With a focus on high-quality, fresh ingredients prepared daily, Polonica Restaurant ensures that each dish offers a genuine taste of Polish culture. The restaurant’s commitment to delivering delicious food has garnered rave reviews, making it a go-to spot for both locals and visitors seeking traditional Polish flavors.

Offering both dine-in and delivery services, Polonica Restaurant provides an inviting atmosphere for lunch or dinner. Their dedication to exceptional quality and customer satisfaction is evident in every aspect of their service. Customers can conveniently order online to enjoy exclusive deals and experience the finest in Polish cuisine from the comfort of their homes. By prioritizing top-notch quality and authenticity, this beloved restaurant continues to share the rich culinary heritage of Poland with its patrons, ensuring a memorable dining experience every time.

(718)3891665

5. Restaurant Relax

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,8/5

68A Newel St, 11222.0, Brooklyn

Polish restaurant

Why we chose them

Restaurant Relax is a hidden gem in NYC, offering a taste of authentic Polish cuisine. Known for its simple eatery style and dedication to traditional Polish fare, this establishment brings the aromas and flavors of Poland to the heart of Greenpoint. Guests rave about standout dishes like pierogies, potato pancakes, and hot borscht, all crafted with care and attention to authenticity. The restaurant’s ambiance is casual and inviting, making it a perfect spot for those seeking comfort food reminiscent of home-cooked meals. With hearty portions and a focus on quality, the eatery ensures a satisfying dining experience for all.

Visitors appreciate the friendly and helpful staff, who are always ready to guide diners through the diverse menu. The establishment stands out for its commitment to providing an excellent dining experience without the need for tips, suggesting fair treatment of their employees. The decor is clean and welcoming, enhancing the overall relaxed atmosphere. This unique combination of delicious food, warm service, and a homey environment makes the restaurant a must-visit for anyone craving authentic Polish flavors in an accessible and enjoyable setting.

6. Jw Real Polish Delicatessen

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

321 Church Ave, 11218.0, Brooklyn

Deli
Grocery store
Polish restaurant

Why we chose them

JW Real Polish Delicatessen stands out in our directory for its authentic Polish culinary offerings. Known for its rich variety of traditional Polish dishes, this establishment offers a diverse menu featuring soups like red borscht and mushroom soup, and main dishes such as breaded chicken cutlets, stuffed cabbage, and Polish pyzy. Customers can also indulge in a selection of pierogi, potato pancakes, and sweet cheese blintzes. Complementing these hearty meals are sides like mashed potatoes, fried vegetables, and a variety of fresh salads, making it a go-to destination for anyone craving genuine Polish flavors.

In addition to its restaurant services, JW Real Polish Delicatessen also functions as a deli and grocery store, providing a wide range of Polish grocery products. From fresh sandwiches and salads to quality bread and coffee, it caters to both breakfast seekers and those looking for homemade dinners. The deli also offers catering services, ensuring that authentic Polish cuisine can be enjoyed at any event. This combination of a traditional deli, grocery store, and restaurant makes it a unique addition to our directory.

(718)3890705

7. Polish & Slavic Center Cafeteria

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,8/5

177 Kent St, 11222.0, Brooklyn

Polish restaurant

Why we chose them

Polish & Slavic Center Cafeteria offers an authentic Polish dining experience, serving as a culinary cornerstone within the Polish Slavic Center in New York. This cafeteria is renowned for its traditional Polish cuisine, providing a taste of home for the Polish community and an inviting introduction for those new to these flavors. With its deep roots in serving the Polish and Slavic populations, the cafeteria is an integral part of the Center’s broader mission to support and celebrate cultural heritage.

As a vital component of the largest Polish-American organization on the East Coast, the cafeteria contributes to the Center’s vibrant community environment. It complements the Center’s various programs, including social services, immigration and legal services, and senior clubs, by offering a space where community members can gather and connect over shared meals. This blend of culture and cuisine makes the cafeteria a significant gathering place, enriching the social fabric of the Polish and Slavic communities it serves.

FAQs

What are some classic Polish dishes I can expect to find at Polish restaurants in Brooklyn?

You can expect to find traditional dishes such as pierogi (dumplings), kielbasa (sausage), bigos (hunter's stew), and barszcz (beet soup) on the menu.

What is the average price range for a meal at a Polish restaurant in Brooklyn?

The average price for a meal at a Polish restaurant in Brooklyn ranges from €9 to €27 per person, depending on the dishes and portion sizes.

Do Polish restaurants in Brooklyn offer vegetarian and vegan options?

Yes, many Polish restaurants in Brooklyn are now offering vegetarian and vegan options, adapting traditional recipes to cater to plant-based diets.

How can I choose the best Polish restaurant for a family outing in Brooklyn?

Look for restaurants with family-friendly menus, a cozy atmosphere, and positive reviews about their service and food quality. It's also helpful to check if they offer special meals for children.

Do Polish restaurants in Brooklyn provide takeout and delivery services?

Yes, many Polish restaurants in Brooklyn offer takeout and delivery services, allowing you to enjoy authentic Polish cuisine at home.

What should I consider when choosing a Polish restaurant for catering an event?

Consider the restaurant's catering menu options, pricing, customer reviews, and their ability to handle the size of your event. It's also important to check their experience in catering for similar events.

Are there any Polish restaurants in Brooklyn that offer a cozy, traditional atmosphere?

Yes, several Polish restaurants in Brooklyn are known for their warm, welcoming environments that mimic a traditional Polish home, often featuring rustic decor and intimate seating arrangements.

What is the typical timeline for ordering catering from a Polish restaurant in Brooklyn?

It's advisable to place your catering order at least one to two weeks in advance to ensure availability and to allow the restaurant ample time to prepare for your event.