Top 7 Best Caterers in Brooklyn

In the vibrant culinary landscape of Brooklyn, finding the perfect caterer for your event can be both exciting and overwhelming. Whether you’re planning a wedding, corporate gathering, or an intimate dinner party, the right catering service can make all the difference. Our guide to the Top 7 Best Caterers in Brooklyn will help you navigate through the diverse options available, ensuring your event is a delicious success.

When selecting a caterer, consider the following services and aspects:

Menu Customization: Tailored options to meet dietary preferences and cultural needs.
Event Planning: Assistance with organizing and coordinating event details.
Presentation: Stylish and professional food presentation.
Staffing: Experienced staff to provide seamless service.
Delivery and Setup: Timely delivery and efficient setup at the venue.
Pricing: Transparent pricing structures starting from $ per person.
Tastings: Opportunity to sample the menu before the event.

Choosing the right caterer involves considering not just the menu, but the overall experience they offer. Dive into our comprehensive guide to discover the best options in Brooklyn that will leave a lasting impression on your guests.

1. Soulfood Caterers
2. La Bagel Delight at Dumbo
3. Lassen & Hennigs

4.
5. Frank & Sal Italian Market Brooklyn
6. Salsa
7. Milk N Honey

Number of companies

3355

Verified reviews

4,49

Average rating

(718)4937570

1. Soulfood Caterers

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,0/5

88a Kingston Ave, 11213.0, Brooklyn

Soul food restaurant
Restaurant
Seafood restaurant

Why we chose them

Soulfood Caterers has carved out a niche as a cash-only mainstay, celebrated for its authentic homestyle grub that keeps customers coming back for more. Known for its inviting atmosphere and delectable offerings, this eatery stands out as a prime choice for anyone craving soulful comfort food. Their focus on delivering quality meals is evident in every bite, making them a beloved spot for food enthusiasts seeking a genuine taste of soul food.

Offering a diverse range of services, including a soul food restaurant, restaurant, and seafood restaurant, they cater to a wide array of culinary preferences. Each dish is crafted with care, reflecting a commitment to tradition and flavor that patrons appreciate. This dedication to quality and authenticity is why we have chosen to feature them in our directory, recognizing their unique contribution to the culinary landscape.

(718)6252235

2. La Bagel Delight at Dumbo

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

104 Front St, 11201.0, Brooklyn

Caterer
Bagel shop
Deli

Why we chose them

La Bagel Delight at Dumbo is renowned for its artisanal hand-rolled bagels, delicious spreads, and hearty sandwiches. As a popular bagel shop, deli, and caterer, they pride themselves on offering top-notch service and quality ingredients. Whether you’re looking for a quick breakfast bite or planning a catered event, their variety of offerings, including cold cut and cream cheese platters, cater to all tastes. Located in the vibrant Dumbo area, they emphasize the importance of supporting local businesses by encouraging direct online orders for delivery and pickup.

The company’s dedication to freshness and quality makes it a standout choice in Brooklyn’s bustling food scene. Known for their efficient delivery service within a two-mile radius, they provide convenience without compromising on taste. Patrons can enjoy the ease of ordering online, ensuring a seamless experience from start to finish. With a commitment to customer satisfaction and community support, this establishment truly embodies the essence of local dining excellence.

(718)8756272

3. Lassen & Hennigs

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

114 Montague St, 11201.0, Brooklyn

Caterer
Bakery
Coffee shop

Why we chose them

Lassen & Hennigs has been a staple in Brooklyn since 1949, offering classic deli and bakery fare with a touch of family tradition. Known for its extensive range of services, including catering, a bakery, and a coffee shop, the company has proudly served the Brooklyn Heights and DUMBO communities for over three generations. Customers can enjoy freshly baked desserts, grab-and-go sandwiches, wraps, and platters, making it a convenient stop for those in a hurry. Their commitment to quality and community makes them a standout choice for delicious meals and event planning.

As a family-owned and operated business, Lassen & Hennigs excels in providing personalized catering services, ensuring that every event is a memorable one. The company’s expertise in crafting cakes and cupcakes for celebrations further enhances their reputation as a go-to catering solution. Their dedication to serving the local community and their ability to adapt to customer needs, whether through online orders or personalized service, highlights their exceptional role in Brooklyn’s culinary landscape.

(718)7633230

4.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,7/5

5909 Avenue N, 11234.0, Brooklyn

Caterer
Butcher shop deli
Grocery store
Meat processor

Why we chose them

Landi’s Pork Store, a staple of Brooklyn since 1928, is renowned for its authentic Italian groceries and exquisite sausages. As a beloved Italian grocer and sausage source, it offers a diverse range of services including catering, a butcher shop deli, a grocery store, and meat processing. Known for its commitment to quality and freshness, the store prepares and ships gourmet Italian specialties, such as dry and fresh sausages, Italian meats, and homemade sauces, directly to customers’ doors. This ensures that the taste of Brooklyn’s rich culinary tradition can be enjoyed anywhere.

The store’s extensive selection features gourmet Italian entrees, sides, fine cheeses, and pasta, all crafted with care. Customers can indulge in popular items like hot and sweet Italian sausage links, homemade ravioli, and rice balls. By offering local pickup and delivery options, the store caters to the needs of New York City residents, providing convenience without compromising on quality. With a dedication to customer satisfaction, the store guarantees the freshness of each order, making it a standout choice for those seeking authentic Italian flavors.

(718)3318100

5. Frank & Sal Italian Market Brooklyn

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,6/5

8008 18th Ave, 11214.0, Brooklyn

Catering food and drink supplier
Italian grocery store
Grocery store

Why we chose them

Frank & Sal Italian Market Brooklyn stands out as a premier destination for authentic Italian grocery items, catering, and deli services. Known for their exceptional selection of artisanal cheeses, cured meats, and handmade pasta, they offer a true taste of Italy. With a commitment to quality, the market meticulously sources products from trusted Italian producers, ensuring each item embodies rich aromas and unforgettable flavors. Catering to both Brooklyn and Staten Island, they provide a seamless shopping experience with free shipping on all orders, allowing customers to savor Italy’s finest culinary delights from the comfort of their homes.

Founded on a legacy of excellence that spans over 65 years, the market continues the tradition of providing fresh, high-quality products. They offer a diverse range of services including Italian grocery options and catering, making them a versatile choice for any occasion. Their dedication to customer satisfaction is evident in their swift delivery and excellent customer service. With specialties like homemade pizza dough and unique sausages, Frank & Sal Italian Market is a gateway to experiencing authentic Italian cuisine and elevating culinary creations to new heights.

(347)5424680

6. Salsa

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,7/5

40 Clifford Pl, 11222.0, Brooklyn

Caterer
Pizza restaurant
Children's party service
Event planner
Party planner
Pizza delivery
Wedding buffet

Why we chose them

Salsa – Pizza Napoletana & Street Food stands out in our directory for its authentic Neapolitan-style pizza, expertly crafted to bring a slice of Naples to every table. This quaint joint is not just a pizza restaurant; it is a vibrant hub for culinary enthusiasts who appreciate the blend of traditional flavors with a street food twist. Known for its diverse offerings, Salsa provides an array of services including catering, event planning, and children’s party services, making it a versatile choice for any occasion.

Beyond its reputation for delectable pizzas, Salsa excels in delivering memorable experiences through its event and party planning services. Whether it’s a wedding buffet or a lively children’s party, their expertise ensures each event is personalized and seamless. Additionally, their efficient pizza delivery service allows customers to enjoy their favorite dishes in the comfort of their own homes. With a commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, Salsa is a top choice for those seeking exceptional culinary experiences.

(718)8714319

7. Milk N Honey

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

5013 10th Ave, 11219.0, Brooklyn

Caterer
Kosher restaurant
Dairy store
Delivery Restaurant
Pizza delivery
Pizza restaurant
Pizza Takeout

Why we chose them

Milk N Honey stands out as a vibrant dairy kosher joint in Brooklyn, offering a diverse global menu that caters to a variety of tastes. As a trusted kosher restaurant, caterer, and dairy store, they provide a rich selection of dishes that includes pizzas, pastas, sandwiches, and more. Their pizza options, such as the Falafel and Bruschetta Pizza, highlight their creative approach to classic favorites, while their breakfast offerings and wide range of salads and soups ensure there’s something for everyone. The restaurant’s commitment to quality and authenticity makes it a beloved spot in the community.

In addition to dining in, customers can enjoy delivery and takeout services, making it convenient to savor their delicious offerings from anywhere. Known for their enticing specials and deals, they cater to both individual and family dining experiences. This adaptability and dedication to customer satisfaction are key reasons why Milk N Honey is a valuable addition to our directory. Whether you’re craving a classic cheese pizza or exploring new flavors, this establishment promises a delightful culinary journey.

FAQs

What services do caterers in Brooklyn typically offer?

Caterers in Brooklyn often provide a range of services including menu customization, event planning, food presentation, staffing, delivery and setup, and tastings to ensure your event is tailored to your needs.

How much does catering typically cost in Brooklyn?

The cost of catering in Brooklyn generally ranges from €40 to €100 per person, depending on the menu complexity, event size, and additional services required.

How far in advance should I book a caterer for my event in Brooklyn?

It's recommended to book a caterer at least 3 to 6 months in advance, especially for large events like weddings or corporate gatherings, to ensure availability and ample time for planning.

What should I consider when choosing a caterer in Brooklyn?

Consider factors such as menu options, experience, reviews, service offerings, pricing transparency, and the ability to accommodate dietary restrictions when choosing a caterer.

Can caterers in Brooklyn accommodate dietary restrictions and preferences?

Yes, many caterers in Brooklyn offer menu customization to accommodate dietary restrictions such as vegan, gluten-free, and kosher options.

Is a tasting session usually included when hiring a caterer in Brooklyn?

Most caterers offer a tasting session as part of their service, allowing you to sample the menu before finalizing your choices for the event.

What level of involvement can I expect from a caterer in the event planning process?

Many caterers offer event planning assistance, helping with organizing details such as venue setup, timeline coordination, and overall event flow to ensure a seamless experience.

Are there any additional costs I should be aware of when hiring a caterer in Brooklyn?

Additional costs may include service charges, rental fees for equipment, and gratuities for staff. It's important to discuss all potential charges upfront for a clear understanding of the total cost.