The 7 Best Hamburger Restaurants in Brooklyn

Brooklyn is a culinary hotspot, and when it comes to finding the best hamburger restaurants, the options are as diverse as the borough itself. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, this guide will help you discover the 7 spots that are flipping the most mouth-watering burgers in town. From classic beef patties to creative vegan options, Brooklyn’s burger scene is a testament to its vibrant and eclectic food culture.

When choosing the perfect hamburger restaurant, consider the following services and aspects:

Menu Variety: Look for places offering a range of burgers, from traditional to gourmet.

Quality Ingredients: Fresh, locally-sourced ingredients can make all the difference.

Price Range: Options can vary from $5 to $20+, so consider what fits your budget.

Atmosphere: Whether it’s a cozy diner or a trendy eatery, the vibe can enhance your dining experience.

Customization Options: The ability to personalize your burger with various toppings and sides.

Service Speed: Quick service is a plus, especially during lunch hours.

Seating Availability: Indoor and outdoor seating can provide different dining experiences.

Takeout and Delivery: Convenient options for enjoying your burger at home.

With this guide, you’ll be well-equipped to embark on a delicious journey through Brooklyn’s finest burger joints. Stay hungry!

1. Shake Shack
2. McDonald's
3. Bareburger

4. Island Trini Burger
5. Shake Shack
6. Rico Chimi
7. Mayfield

Number of companies

12898

Verified reviews

4,14

Average rating

(347)4427711

1. Shake Shack

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,2/5

170 Flatbush Ave, 11217.0, Brooklyn

Hamburger restaurant
American restaurant
Catering food and drink supplier
Caterer
Chicken restaurant
Dessert restaurant
Fast food restaurant
Lunch restaurant
Takeout Restaurant
Sandwich shop

Why we chose them

Shake Shack Flatbush – Barclays Ctr is a standout destination in Brooklyn, offering a delightful fusion of gourmet burgers and frozen custard. This American restaurant is part of a renowned chain that originated from a humble hot dog cart in Manhattan’s Madison Square Park. Known for its fresh, simple, and high-quality classics, the venue has become a lively community hub attracting locals and visitors alike. With a diverse menu that includes burgers, chicken, hot dogs, and desserts, this location caters to a wide array of tastes, ensuring every guest finds something to savor.

In addition to its dine-in experience, the company excels as a catering food and drink supplier and takeout restaurant, offering convenience and flexibility through its app for ordering ahead. Patrons can enjoy exclusive app promotions, new menu items, and even birthday surprises. The emphasis on customer satisfaction is mirrored in their commitment to teamwork and community support. By fostering a fun and collaborative environment, this location not only serves delicious food but also stands as a testament to their mission to “Stand For Something Good” in the fast-paced hospitality industry.

(718)9961029

2. McDonald's

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 3,6/5

606 Neptune Ave, 11224.0, Brooklyn

Hamburger restaurant
Breakfast restaurant
Coffee shop
Fast food restaurant
Restaurant
Sandwich shop

Why we chose them

McDonald’s, an iconic fast-food burger and fries chain, has become a staple in the quick-service restaurant industry since 1954. Known for its quality food and affordable prices, it offers a diverse menu that includes burgers, McNuggets®, sandwiches, and the famous McCafé® coffee. The restaurant caters to a wide range of tastes with its breakfast offerings, meal deals, and the popular $1 $2 $3 Dollar Menu. Customers can enjoy their meals in a variety of settings, such as the hamburger restaurant, breakfast restaurant, fast food restaurant, and sandwich shop, ensuring a convenient and satisfying dining experience.

Committed to enhancing the customer experience, the company provides numerous amenities and services, such as Mobile Order & Pay via their app, allowing for seamless ordering and pickup. Additionally, McDelivery® through partners like DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub ensures that delicious meals are delivered directly to customers’ doors. The restaurant also offers free Wi-Fi, making it an ideal spot for those on the go. By continuously evolving its services and maintaining a focus on customer satisfaction, this fast-food giant remains a beloved choice for many seeking a quick and enjoyable meal.

(347)5296673

3. Bareburger

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

149 Court St, 11201.0, Brooklyn

Hamburger restaurant
American restaurant
Bar
Chicken restaurant
Chicken wings restaurant
Salad shop

Why we chose them

Bareburger stands out as an eco-conscious regional burger chain dedicated to serving organic, quality burgers since 2009. With a commitment to sustainability, this vibrant eatery offers an extensive menu that caters to diverse appetites, featuring options like primo organic grass-fed beef, all-natural bison, and plant-based veggie patties. Known for its mindful dining experience, the company ensures every bite is packed with flavor while maintaining a focus on ethical sourcing and premium ingredients. Whether you’re a carnivore or a veggie enthusiast, Bareburger’s menu promises deliciously different and feel-good food for everyone.

Beyond its commitment to eco-friendly dining, Bareburger also excels as a hamburger restaurant, American restaurant, bar, chicken restaurant, chicken wings restaurant, and salad shop. Their offerings, including the new wagyu beef smash burgers in classic Oklahoma style, highlight the brand’s innovative approach to traditional American cuisine. The company also provides sustainable catering services, ensuring events are memorable with mouthwatering options that delight guests. By blending extraordinary flavors with environmental responsibility, Bareburger has carved a niche as a leader in sustainable dining.

(718)4952474

4. Island Trini Burger

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 3,9/5

504 Utica Ave, 11203.0, Brooklyn

Hamburger restaurant
Fast food restaurant

Why we chose them

Island Burger stands out as a no-frills joint offering eclectic burgers that cater to diverse tastes. This establishment is renowned for its unique take on the classic hamburger, blending traditional flavors with an innovative twist that keeps customers coming back for more. As both a Hamburger restaurant and a Fast food restaurant, it provides a convenient dining option for those seeking a quick yet satisfying meal. Its emphasis on quality and creativity makes it a must-visit destination for burger enthusiasts.

With options for both pickup and delivery, Island Burger ensures that delicious meals are accessible to everyone, whether you’re dining in or enjoying your meal at home. The website makes it easy to find nearby locations and place orders, reflecting the company’s commitment to customer convenience. This seamless service, combined with its eclectic menu, makes Island Burger a valuable addition to our directory, highlighting its role in the fast food industry.

(929)4270420

5. Shake Shack

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,3/5

160 Berry St, 11249.0, Brooklyn

Hamburger restaurant
American restaurant
Catering food and drink supplier
Caterer
Chicken restaurant
Dessert restaurant
Fast food restaurant
Lunch restaurant
Takeout Restaurant
Sandwich shop

Why we chose them

Shake Shack Williamsburg offers a delightful twist on American classics with their gourmet approach to fast food. Known for serving made-to-order Angus beef burgers, crispy chicken, and hand-spun milkshakes, this location stands out by using only the best ingredients. Guests can enjoy a variety of options, including house-made lemonades, beer, and wine, all crafted to ensure a high-quality dining experience. The establishment is not only a popular hamburger and chicken restaurant but also serves as a dessert, fast food, lunch, and takeout restaurant, making it a versatile choice for various dining needs.

The Williamsburg location of this cult-favorite chain embodies the brand’s commitment to community and quality. With a mission to Stand for Something Good®, the company invests in both its employees and the neighborhood, creating a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Guests can enjoy the convenience of ordering online or through the Shack App, ensuring they never have to wait in line again. This location exemplifies Shake Shack’s dedication to providing uplifting experiences through its premium offerings and friendly hospitality, making it an essential addition to our directory for those seeking elevated fast food in a lively setting.

(347)7157272

6. Rico Chimi

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,0/5

2928 Atlantic Ave, 11207.0, Brooklyn

Hamburger restaurant
Delivery Restaurant

Why we chose them

Rico Chimi stands out as a top destination for those seeking the best chimi in New York. Known for its original recipes crafted with fresh, locally sourced ingredients, this hamburger and delivery restaurant offers a menu filled with mouth-watering options such as mofonguitos de pollo, chimi de res, and camarofongo. Customers are drawn to its inviting atmosphere, where quality foods and drinks are served daily. With a commitment to fast delivery, every meal is guaranteed to arrive hot and fresh, making it a convenient choice for both dining in and ordering out.

Offering more than just a dining experience, the restaurant provides catering services for events of all sizes, ensuring guests enjoy the same delicious flavors at any gathering. With enticing daily specials like Mexican Tuesday and Dominican Thursday, there’s always something new to try. Additionally, their mobile app offers the convenience of ordering with just a few clicks and the opportunity to save up to 15%. Whether it’s for a quick bite or a special occasion, Rico Chimi promises an unforgettable flavor journey.

(347)3183643

7. Mayfield

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

688 Franklin Ave, 11238.0, Brooklyn

Hamburger restaurant
American restaurant

Why we chose them

Mayfield has been a staple in the Crown Heights neighborhood since 2012, offering a vibrant atmosphere that combines stylish deco aesthetics with a menu of New American fare. The restaurant specializes in quality interpretations of classic American dishes, using fresh, seasonal ingredients prepared in a simple yet creative way. Patrons can enjoy a diverse dining experience, from savoring a hamburger and a beer at the bar while watching the game to indulging in a four-course meal paired with hand-picked wines and cocktails. Known for being Brooklyn’s neighborhood favorite, it caters to a variety of tastes and occasions.

Offering both a hamburger restaurant and an American restaurant experience, Mayfield provides an extensive menu that includes enticing options like oyster specials, brunch offerings, and a wide selection of wines and cocktails. Their commitment to quality is evident in their focus on fresh ingredients and innovative menu items. Guests can easily order online for pick-up or delivery, making it a convenient choice for those looking to enjoy their meals at home. Whether it’s a casual night out or a special gathering, Mayfield delivers a memorable dining experience with its warm ambiance and diverse culinary offerings.

FAQs

What should I look for in a good hamburger restaurant in Brooklyn?

Consider menu variety, quality of ingredients, price range, atmosphere, customization options, service speed, seating availability, and takeout or delivery options.

What is the average price range for a hamburger in Brooklyn?

Hamburgers in Brooklyn typically range from €4.50 to €18.50, depending on the restaurant and the type of burger.

Do hamburger restaurants in Brooklyn offer vegan options?

Yes, many hamburger restaurants in Brooklyn offer creative vegan options alongside traditional beef patties.

How can I customize my burger at these restaurants?

Most places allow you to personalize your burger with various toppings, sauces, and sides, ensuring a unique dining experience.

Are there any hamburger restaurants with outdoor seating in Brooklyn?

Yes, several hamburger restaurants in Brooklyn provide outdoor seating, offering a pleasant dining atmosphere, especially in nice weather.

How long does it typically take to get served at a hamburger restaurant in Brooklyn?

Service speed varies, but many places offer quick service, especially during lunch hours, with wait times generally ranging from 10 to 30 minutes.

Do these restaurants offer takeout and delivery services?

Yes, most hamburger restaurants in Brooklyn offer convenient takeout and delivery options, perfect for enjoying a burger at home.

How do I choose the best hamburger restaurant for my taste in Brooklyn?

Identify what aspects are most important to you, such as menu variety, atmosphere, or price, and explore reviews and recommendations to find a spot that matches your preferences.