Top 7 Best Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn

Brooklyn is a vibrant tapestry of cultures and cuisines, and among its culinary treasures, Italian dining holds a special place. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, discovering the authentic flavors of Italy without leaving the borough is a delight. In this guide, we’ll explore the Top 7 Best Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn, each offering a unique taste of Italy’s rich culinary heritage.

Before diving into our curated list, it’s important to consider the services and aspects that make an Italian restaurant stand out. Here are some key features to look for:

Traditional Dishes: Look for menus that offer classic Italian dishes, from pasta to risotto, and regional specialties.
Authentic Ingredients: Quality ingredients, such as extra virgin olive oil and San Marzano tomatoes, are a hallmark of genuine Italian cuisine.
Wine Selection: A well-curated list of Italian wines, from Chianti to Prosecco, can enhance your dining experience.
Ambiance: The atmosphere should evoke the charm of Italy, whether it’s a rustic trattoria or a chic modern eatery.
Service: Warm, knowledgeable service that can guide you through the menu and offer pairing suggestions.
Price Range: Italian dining in Brooklyn can range from affordable pasta dishes around $15 to gourmet experiences that may exceed $50 per entrée.

With these aspects in mind, let’s delve into the top Italian dining spots that Brooklyn has to offer. Whether you’re in the mood for a cozy, family-run establishment or a trendy, upscale venue, our guide will help you find the perfect place to indulge in the best Italian cuisine Brooklyn has to offer.

1. Gino's
2. Barboncino Pizza
3. Forma Pasta Factory

4. Ignazio's
5. Carmine's
6. Michael's of Brooklyn
7. John's Deli

Number of companies

11322

Verified reviews

4,47

Average rating

(718)7481698

1. Gino's

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,6/5

7414 5th Ave, 11209.0, Brooklyn

Italian restaurant
Bar
Pizza restaurant

Why we chose them

Gino’s is a cherished Italian old-timer known for its delectable red-sauce classics, offering a genuine taste of Italy in the heart of Brooklyn. This renowned establishment serves as an Italian restaurant, bar, and pizza restaurant, bringing together a delightful blend of flavors and experiences. With an inviting atmosphere, patrons can enjoy a range of services, including dining in, catering for private events, and the convenience of ordering online. The restaurant is a favorite among locals and visitors alike, making it an essential stop for anyone craving authentic Italian cuisine.

At Gino’s, guests are treated to a meticulously curated menu that showcases classic Italian dishes alongside creative specials that keep the culinary experience fresh and exciting. The establishment is not just about food; it offers a complete dining experience with options for reservations and gift cards, adding a touch of elegance and convenience. Whether it’s a casual night out or a special occasion, this beloved spot caters to diverse tastes and preferences, making it a standout choice for inclusion in our company directory.

(718)4838834

2. Barboncino Pizza

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

781 Franklin Ave, 11238.0, Brooklyn

Italian restaurant
Bar
Pizza restaurant
Neapolitan restaurant
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Located in the vibrant neighborhood of Crown Heights, Brooklyn, Barboncino Pizza stands out as a bustling brick-oven pizzeria that has been delighting guests since 2011. Known for its authentic Neapolitan-style offerings, this Italian restaurant also features a lively bar scene, making it a popular spot for both dinner and brunch. Its cozy atmosphere, coupled with a commitment to quality, ensures that patrons enjoy a genuine taste of Italy with every visit.

Offering a diverse array of services, including a dedicated pizza restaurant and a full-service bar, Barboncino has become a staple in the Brooklyn dining scene. The establishment is celebrated for its expertly crafted pizzas, which are baked to perfection in their signature brick oven. Whether you’re indulging in a leisurely brunch or savoring a late-night dinner, the restaurant provides a welcoming environment that captures the essence of a traditional Neapolitan experience.

(718)3492009

3. Forma Pasta Factory

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,6/5

14 Bedford Ave, 11222.0, Brooklyn

Italian restaurant
Pasta shop

Why we chose them

Forma Pasta Factory is a celebrated fast-casual hub known for its exquisite housemade pasta, offering a unique blend of traditional Italian flavors with a modern twist. As both an Italian restaurant and pasta shop, it provides an inviting atmosphere where guests can enjoy freshly crafted pasta dishes that highlight the authenticity and passion behind each creation. This dedication to quality and innovation makes it a noteworthy addition to our company directory, appealing to pasta enthusiasts and casual diners alike.

The establishment stands out by engaging its customers through a user-friendly website powered by BentoBox, which offers seamless navigation to explore their menu, learn about the company’s story, and stay updated through Instagram. This digital presence complements their physical locations, creating an immersive experience that invites patrons to dive deeper into the world of Italian cuisine. The combination of delicious offerings and a strong online platform underscores the company’s commitment to accessibility and customer satisfaction, making it a prime example of culinary excellence in the fast-casual sector.

(718)5222100

4. Ignazio's

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,0/5

4 Water St, 11201.0, Brooklyn

Italian restaurant
Pizza restaurant
Delivery Restaurant
Takeout Restaurant
Pizza delivery
Pizza Takeout
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Ignazio’s is a charming pizza joint nestled under the iconic Brooklyn Bridge, offering a delightful blend of classic and specialty pizzas that have become a staple in Brooklyn. This Italian restaurant is known for its fresh ingredients and impeccable service, catering to both in-house diners and those preferring delivery or takeout. The menu features everything from traditional pizzas with fresh mozzarella and Italian plum tomatoes to adventurous options like the Bacon, Avocado & Tomato Pizza. The cozy atmosphere and commitment to quality make it a must-visit spot for pizza lovers.

Beyond its renowned pizza offerings, Ignazio’s provides a diverse menu that includes calzones, wraps, heros, and a variety of appetizers and salads. Their DIY pizza kit allows customers to recreate the pizzeria experience at home, emphasizing their dedication to quality and customer satisfaction. With services such as free delivery and easy online ordering through Slice, this restaurant ensures a seamless dining experience. Whether dining in or enjoying a meal at home, customers can expect a taste of authentic Italian cuisine right in the heart of Brooklyn.

(718)7829659

5. Carmine's

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

358 Graham Ave, 11211.0, Brooklyn

Italian restaurant
Bar
Event venue
Pizza restaurant
Pizza delivery
Pizza Takeout
Restaurant
Sports bar

Why we chose them

Carmine’s is a beloved classic neighborhood Italian restaurant offering a delightful culinary experience in Brooklyn. Known for its delicious NY-style and Sicilian pizzas, the restaurant features a diverse menu that caters to a wide range of tastes. From specialty pies like the Grandma Vodka Pizza to gluten-free options, Carmine’s ensures there’s something for everyone. Beyond pizza, patrons can enjoy a variety of appetizers, homemade soups, salads, and Italian specialty dishes. For those seeking a hearty meal, the hot and cold heroes and a selection of pasta dishes provide satisfying choices. The venue also serves as a lively bar and sports bar, enhancing its appeal as a social gathering spot.

In addition to its dine-in experience, Carmine’s offers convenient services such as pizza delivery and takeout, making it easy for customers to enjoy their meals at home. As an event venue, it can host gatherings and celebrations, adding to its role as a community hub. Empowered by the Slice app, online orders are a breeze, allowing customers to enjoy free delivery of their favorite dishes. With its welcoming atmosphere and extensive menu, Carmine’s stands out as a top choice for Italian cuisine lovers and food enthusiasts in the area.

(718)9987851

6. Michael's of Brooklyn

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,7/5

2929 Avenue R, 11229.0, Brooklyn

Italian restaurant
Fine dining restaurant
Restaurant
Seafood restaurant

Why we chose them

Michael’s of Brooklyn stands as a beacon of Italian culinary excellence, offering upscale Italian fare in an elegantly appointed setting. Family-owned and operated since 1964, this fine dining restaurant has become a beloved institution in Brooklyn, celebrated for its generations-old family recipes. Guests are invited to indulge in a rich array of dishes, from warm and cold antipasti to tantalizing pasta creations, delectable seafood, and exquisite veal and poultry entrees. The warm and friendly staff enhances the dining experience, making every visit memorable.

Aside from being a distinguished Italian restaurant, Michael’s also takes pride in its unique offering: the only nationally sold pasta sauce cooked and packed at the source. This dedication to quality and tradition resonates with both local patrons and visitors from afar. Customers can explore their extensive menu, featuring today’s specials, catering options, and tempting desserts. With a reputation built on decades of excellence, the restaurant continues to thrive, inviting diners to celebrate the authentic tastes of Italy.

(718)3727481

7. John's Deli

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

2033 Stillwell Ave, 11223.0, Brooklyn

Italian restaurant
Caterer
Deli
Sandwich shop
Takeout Restaurant
Restaurant

Why we chose them

John’s Deli, a beloved family-owned establishment in Brooklyn since 1968, is renowned for its commitment to delivering high-quality Italian-style eats. As a cherished sandwich shop, it offers an impressive array of hot and cold sandwiches, embodying the classic New York deli experience. With a reputation for flavorful dishes and an inviting atmosphere, it’s no wonder that locals rave about their iconic sandwiches, including favorites like the Johnny Roast Beef and the Jimmy Conway. The deli’s dedication to quality and reasonable pricing has made it a staple for both residents and visitors seeking authentic Italian flavors.

In addition to being a celebrated Italian restaurant and deli, the establishment also excels as a caterer, providing a wide variety of plates and hot food trays for events ranging from corporate gatherings to weddings. Their menu features cleverly named creations, each crafted to perfection, ensuring a memorable dining experience. The deli also functions as a takeout restaurant, offering convenient options for those on the go. With glowing reviews highlighting their delicious offerings and exceptional service, it’s clear why this spot remains a top choice in Brooklyn’s culinary scene.

FAQs

What services can I expect from an Italian restaurant in Brooklyn?

Italian restaurants in Brooklyn typically offer a range of services including dine-in, takeout, delivery, catering for events, and sometimes private dining experiences. Many also offer wine pairing recommendations to enhance your meal.

What is the average price range for a meal at an Italian restaurant in Brooklyn?

The price range for a meal at an Italian restaurant in Brooklyn can vary significantly. On average, you can expect to spend between €14 to €48 per entrée, depending on the restaurant's style and menu offerings.

How can I choose a good Italian restaurant in Brooklyn?

To choose a good Italian restaurant, consider factors such as the authenticity of the menu, the quality of ingredients, the ambiance, the service, and reviews from other diners. Checking if the restaurant has a good selection of Italian wines can also be a plus.

What traditional Italian dishes should I look for on the menu?

Look for classic dishes such as pasta varieties like carbonara and bolognese, risottos, pizza, and regional specialties like osso buco or saltimbocca. A good Italian restaurant should also offer antipasti and traditional desserts like tiramisu.

What are some key ingredients that indicate authentic Italian cuisine?

Key ingredients to look for include extra virgin olive oil, San Marzano tomatoes, Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese, and balsamic vinegar. These ingredients are often used in authentic Italian cooking and indicate quality.

How important is the wine selection at an Italian restaurant?

A well-curated wine selection is important as it enhances the dining experience. Look for a variety of Italian wines such as Chianti, Barolo, and Prosecco, which can be paired with different dishes for a complete culinary experience.

What should I consider about the ambiance of an Italian restaurant?

The ambiance should reflect the charm of Italy, whether it's a cozy, rustic trattoria or a modern, elegant space. The atmosphere should be inviting and comfortable, enhancing your overall dining experience.

Are there any specific times when Italian restaurants in Brooklyn are less crowded?

Italian restaurants in Brooklyn are generally less crowded during weekday lunch hours and early weekday dinners. It's always a good idea to make a reservation, especially during peak dinner times on weekends.