The 7 Best Pizza Restaurants in Brooklyn

Brooklyn is a haven for pizza lovers, offering a diverse array of options that range from classic slices to innovative pies. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, discovering the perfect slice can be a thrilling journey. This guide highlights the 7 best pizza restaurants in Brooklyn, each bringing something unique to the table.

When selecting a pizza spot, consider the following services and aspects:

Wood-fired ovens for authentic flavor
Delivery and takeout options
Outdoor seating for enjoying your pizza al fresco
Vegan and gluten-free options
Family-friendly atmosphere
Specialty pizzas with unique toppings
Happy hour deals and specials
Local ingredients and farm-to-table practices

Prices can vary, with a typical slice ranging from $3 to $5, while a whole pie might cost anywhere from $15 to $30 or more, depending on the toppings and the restaurant’s reputation. Dive into the post to uncover the top spots that make Brooklyn a pizza paradise.

1. Joe's Pizza
2. Lucali
3. Artichoke Basille's Pizza

4. Original Pizza
5. Pizza Wagon
6. Dellarocco's Brick Oven Pizza
7. My Little Pizzeria

Number of companies

12706

Verified reviews

4,41

Average rating

(718)3882216

1. Joe's Pizza

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

216 Bedford Ave, 11249.0, Brooklyn

Pizza restaurant
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Joe’s Pizza, a classic New York-style pizzeria, has been serving authentic slices in Greenwich Village since 1975. Founded by Joe Pozzuoli, who hails from Naples, Italy, the birthplace of pizza, this establishment has become a beloved institution among both locals and tourists. Known for its traditional New York street slice, the restaurant originally operated at the corner of Bleecker and Carmine Street and now resides just three doors down at 7 Carmine Street. Joe, at 75 years old, continues to own and operate the restaurant, maintaining its reputation for quality and authenticity.

Visitors flock to this iconic eatery to experience the quintessential New York pizza experience. Over the years, it has gained fame not only for its delicious offerings but also for its rich history and commitment to tradition. The pizzeria stands out in our directory as a must-visit destination for anyone seeking genuine New York-style pizza, embodying the vibrant culture and culinary heritage of the city. With a legacy spanning over 47 years, Joe’s dedication to his craft ensures that every slice served is a testament to the time-honored techniques and flavors that define a true New York classic.

(718)8584086

2. Lucali

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,3/5

575 Henry St, 11231.0, Brooklyn

Pizza restaurant
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Lucali, a shabby-chic NY-style pizzeria and wine bar, has earned its place in our directory for its unique origin and commitment to preserving local culture. Founded by accidental pizzaiolo Mark Iacono, the restaurant was born from a heartfelt mission to save a beloved Carroll Gardens candy store. This labor of love has since transformed into a celebrated destination, offering an authentic taste of New York with its distinct pizzas and cozy ambiance.

Offering services as a pizza restaurant and restaurant, Lucali has expanded beyond its Brooklyn roots to Miami, capturing the essence of a true New York pizzeria in each location. The brand’s story of passion and community preservation resonates with patrons who appreciate not just the flavors, but also the heartfelt history behind them. Their ability to provide a warm and inviting atmosphere makes it a standout choice for pizza enthusiasts and those seeking a genuine dining experience.

(718)3860333

3. Artichoke Basille's Pizza

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,2/5

18 Wyckoff Ave, 11237.0, Brooklyn

Pizza restaurant
Bar
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Artichoke Basille’s Pizza stands out in our directory for its unique blend of services as a pizza restaurant, bar, and dining establishment. Known for its petite storefront and late hours, it caters to those seeking delicious pizza options well into the night. The company has made a name for itself with its signature pizzas, which can now be enjoyed nationwide thanks to their shipping service. This accessibility, coupled with the ability to order online, makes it a convenient choice for pizza lovers everywhere.

With a focus on customer engagement, Artichoke Basille’s Pizza maintains an active presence on social media platforms like Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram. Their website, powered by BentoBox, offers a seamless navigation experience with features like email signup for updates and information about franchising opportunities. The brand’s commitment to accessibility and customer interaction highlights why it is a notable addition to our company directory.

(718)4445007

4. Original Pizza

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

2351 Ralph Ave, 11234.0, Brooklyn

Pizza restaurant
Delivery Restaurant
Restaurant

Why we chose them

Original Pizza, a beloved fixture in Brooklyn, has been serving the community for over 50 years. Known as a no-nonsense spot for slices and pies, this establishment embodies the essence of a classic pizza restaurant. With a focus on quality and tradition, it’s a place that feels like home to many locals. The restaurant not only offers dine-in options but also excels as a delivery restaurant, ensuring that their delicious offerings can be enjoyed anywhere in the area. This dedication to service and taste is why it stands out in our directory.

The commitment of Original Pizza to its community is evident through its decades-long presence, a testament to its popularity and the loyalty of its patrons. The restaurant’s menu is a dream that has been cooking for years, reflecting a deep-seated passion for authentic pizza. Open late into the night, it caters to both early diners and night owls alike. This steadfast dedication to quality and customer satisfaction makes it a noteworthy addition to any list of must-visit pizza spots in Brooklyn.

(718)8365725

5. Pizza Wagon

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

8610 5th Ave, 11209.0, Brooklyn

Pizza restaurant
Italian restaurant
Delivery Restaurant

Why we chose them

Pizza Wagon stands out as a delightful choice for anyone craving authentic Italian flavors in a relaxed setting. This casual counter-serve joint has carved a niche for itself with its mouth-watering pizzas, offering a satisfying experience for both dine-in and takeout. Its reputation as a beloved pizza restaurant is well-earned, thanks to its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, this spot delivers an inviting atmosphere perfect for any pizza lover.

What makes Pizza Wagon a must-include in our directory is its versatility as both a delivery restaurant and an Italian restaurant. The convenience of delivery ensures that delicious, hot pizza can be enjoyed from the comfort of your home, while the dine-in option offers a cozy place to gather with friends and family. With its focus on providing exceptional service and flavorful dishes, this establishment truly embodies the essence of Italian cuisine, making it a standout choice for pizza enthusiasts.

(718)8581010

6. Dellarocco's Brick Oven Pizza

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,6/5

214 Hicks St, 11201.0, Brooklyn

Pizza restaurant
Bar

Why we chose them

Dellarocco’s Brick Oven Pizza has established itself as a cherished neighborhood bistro since opening in August 2012. Known for its authentic wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas, it offers a warm and casual dining experience. Patrons can enjoy the vibrant atmosphere with a view of the distinctive “ferrari red” wood-burning oven. Located just a block from the Brooklyn Promenade, this family-owned gem in Brooklyn is a perfect spot to enjoy a delicious meal with friends.

The restaurant features a bar with 12 rotating draft beers, including many local microbrews, and a thoughtfully curated selection of wines, focusing on Italian varietals. This emphasis on quality beverages complements their exquisite pizza offerings, making it a popular choice for both locals and visitors. As a testament to its community roots, the eatery also provides free delivery within Brooklyn Heights, further solidifying its status as a beloved local institution.

(718)6436120

7. My Little Pizzeria

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

114 Court St, 11201.0, Brooklyn

Pizza restaurant

Why we chose them

My Little Pizzeria, a pizza-by-the-slice specialist, has carved out a beloved niche in Brooklyn’s vibrant food scene. Known for its classic cheese and customizable pizzas, this popular spot offers a delightful array of round and square pies. Whether you’re in the mood for a simple slice or a specialty pizza like the Vegetable or Supreme, each dish is made with fresh ingredients, including homemade mozzarella and ripe tomatoes. The menu also features a variety of delicious options such as calzones, garlic knots, and fresh salads, ensuring there’s something for every palate.

What sets this pizza restaurant apart is its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, making it a favorite among locals. With convenient services like curbside pickup and free delivery, enjoying their tasty offerings is easy and accessible. As a partner of Slice for eight years, the restaurant continues to thrive and cater to the community, offering reliable and mouth-watering meals. Embrace a true taste of Brooklyn with a visit to this charming eatery, where every bite promises to deliver a delightful flavor experience.

FAQs

What makes a pizza restaurant one of the best in Brooklyn?

A top pizza restaurant in Brooklyn often features wood-fired ovens for authentic flavor, offers diverse menu options including vegan and gluten-free choices, and uses local, farm-to-table ingredients. Additionally, a welcoming atmosphere and unique specialty pizzas contribute to its reputation.

What are the average prices for pizza in Brooklyn?

In Brooklyn, a typical slice ranges from €2.80 to €4.70, while a whole pie can cost between €14 and €28 or more, depending on the toppings and the restaurant's reputation.

Do these pizza restaurants in Brooklyn offer delivery and takeout services?

Yes, many pizza restaurants in Brooklyn offer delivery and takeout options. It’s a good idea to check with the specific restaurant for their delivery area and any associated fees.

How can I choose a good pizza restaurant in Brooklyn?

Consider factors such as the type of oven used, menu diversity, atmosphere, and customer reviews. Additionally, look for restaurants that offer unique toppings and use high-quality, local ingredients.

Are there pizza restaurants in Brooklyn with outdoor seating?

Yes, several pizza restaurants in Brooklyn offer outdoor seating, allowing you to enjoy your meal al fresco. It's best to check the restaurant's website or call ahead to confirm seating availability.

What should I consider when selecting a pizza restaurant for a family outing?

Look for a family-friendly atmosphere, a menu with options for all ages, and amenities such as high chairs or children’s menus. Some restaurants also offer special deals for families.

Do Brooklyn pizza restaurants offer happy hour deals?

Many pizza restaurants in Brooklyn offer happy hour deals and specials. These can include discounts on pizzas, drinks, or combo offers. Checking the restaurant’s website or social media can provide current promotions.

What are the benefits of choosing a pizza restaurant that uses local ingredients?

Choosing a restaurant that uses local ingredients often means fresher produce and a more sustainable dining experience. It also supports local farmers and can enhance the overall taste and quality of the pizza.