The 7 Best Toy Stores in Brooklyn

Brooklyn is a vibrant hub of creativity and culture, making it the perfect place to discover unique and exciting toy stores. Whether you’re searching for the perfect gift or simply want to explore imaginative spaces, our guide to the 7 Best Toy Stores in Brooklyn will lead you to enchanting destinations filled with wonder and delight. From classic wooden toys to the latest tech gadgets, these stores offer something for every child—and the young at heart.

When choosing a toy store, consider the following aspects and services that can enhance your shopping experience:

Personalized Service – Friendly staff to help you find the perfect toy.
Unique Selection – A diverse range of toys, including handmade and eco-friendly options.
Play Areas – Interactive spaces where children can test toys and play.
Gift Wrapping – Convenient services to wrap your purchases beautifully.
Events and Workshops – Engaging activities for children and families.
Loyalty Programs – Discounts and rewards for regular customers.

Each of these Brooklyn toy stores offers a unique experience, ensuring that your visit is both enjoyable and memorable. Dive into our full guide to explore all the playful treasures that await you in Brooklyn!

1. Barnes & Noble
2. Five Below
3. Dii Deals & Discounts

4. St-Petersburg Books & Gifts Store and Toys for Kids
5.
6. Carter's
7. Brooklyn Superhero Supply Co

Number of companies

7484

Verified reviews

4,46

Average rating

(718)8329066

1. Barnes & Noble

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,5/5

267 7th Ave, 11215.0, Brooklyn

Toy store
Cafe
Children's book store
Hobby store
Book store

Why we chose them

Barnes & Noble is a cherished destination in Park Slope, NY, offering a rich array of books, magazines, and more. Known for its inviting atmosphere, this location is more than just a bookstore. It features a delightful Café where visitors can enjoy a relaxing break, a dedicated Children’s Book Store section to inspire young readers, and a Toy Store that captivates all ages. Additionally, the store serves as a Hobby Store, providing enthusiasts with a variety of materials to fuel their creativity. This multifaceted approach makes it a vibrant community hub where literary enthusiasts and families gather.

The store frequently hosts engaging events, enhancing its role as a cultural hotspot. Regular Storytime sessions delight children every Wednesday and Saturday, nurturing a love for reading from an early age. Special events like the “Diary of a Wimpy Kid #19 – Hot Mess” release party and Lego Build sessions further enrich its offerings. Virtual author events featuring renowned writers such as Louise Penny and David Baldacci invite book lovers to connect with their favorite authors, making this location not just a retail space but a center for literary engagement and community connection.

(718)8272507

2. Five Below

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

470 Gateway Dr, 11239.0, Brooklyn

Toy store
Candy store
Fashion accessories store
Gift shop
Variety store

Why we chose them

Five Below offers a vibrant and engaging shopping experience tailored for tweens, teens, and beyond. Located at the Gateway Center North in Brooklyn, NY, this lively store is a haven for those seeking affordable novelty items, games, and toys. With a focus on delivering extreme value, Five Below features a diverse array of products across eight exciting worlds: Tech, Style, Room, Play, Create, Party, Candy, and New & Now. Shoppers can explore fashion accessories, remote control toys, beauty products, and more, all designed to spark joy and creativity.

Renowned for its teen-oriented merchandise, Five Below doubles as a toy store, candy store, fashion accessories store, gift shop, and variety store. The store promises a color-popping and music-pumping environment where customers can let go and have fun. Its commitment to bringing the “WOW” factor ensures that every visit is a chance to discover incredible finds beyond the typical $1-$5 range. Whether you’re on the hunt for trendy tech gadgets, stylish tees, or delicious candy, Five Below provides endless possibilities to say “YES” and smile big.

(718)2657099

3. Dii Deals & Discounts

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

626 Sheepshead Bay Rd, 11224.0, Brooklyn

Discount store
Christmas store
Clothing store
Department store
Toy store
Variety store

Why we chose them

DII Deals & Discounts is a versatile and engaging shopping destination that offers a wide range of products to meet the needs of diverse customers. Known for its extensive selection of discounted items, DII serves as a discount store, Christmas store, clothing store, department store, toy store, and variety store. The company is committed to providing high-quality products at affordable prices, featuring popular categories such as health and personal care, clothing and shoes, kitchen and household items, groceries, snacks, office supplies, and toys and games. With a focus on delivering value, DII is a go-to choice for budget-conscious shoppers.

Offering a wide array of brands like Dove, Fisher-Price, Mattel, and Disney, DII ensures that customers have access to trusted names they love. The store frequently updates its inventory with new arrivals and special deals, making it an ever-evolving shopping experience. Customers can explore everything from baby and child care products to seasonal items, ensuring they find exactly what they need for any occasion. DII’s commitment to quality and customer satisfaction makes it a valued addition to our directory, providing exceptional savings and variety to the communities it serves.

(718)8916778

4. St-Petersburg Books & Gifts Store and Toys for Kids

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

221 Brighton Beach Ave, 11235.0, Brooklyn

Toy store
Gift shop
Home goods store
Souvenir store
Book store

Why we chose them

St-Petersburg Books & Gifts Store and Toys for Kids is a vibrant destination offering an eclectic mix of Russian books, home goods, unique gifts, and a wide array of toys for children and teenagers. This mellow store stands out with its diverse selection, catering to those seeking cultural and collectible items. With a focus on quality and variety, the store features everything from classic literature and new releases to educational toys and creative games, providing a rich shopping experience for families and individuals alike.

The store excels as a multifaceted shopping experience, functioning as a toy store, gift shop, home goods store, souvenir store, and book store. Customers can explore an impressive range of products including porcelain, cookware, and decorative items, alongside special festive gifts and seasonal collections. The store’s commitment to delivering an engaging and comprehensive shopping experience makes it a valuable addition to our directory, appealing to those interested in cultural enrichment and unique, high-quality products.

(718)4358697

5.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,7/5

4714 13th Ave, 11219.0, Brooklyn

Toy store

Why we chose them

Toys 4 U stands out as a premier toy store, offering a wide range of high-quality toys and games. Known for its extensive selection of popular brands, it provides everything from educational STEM toys to beloved figures like Hello Kitty and Playmobil. The store’s diverse categories include building toys, arts and crafts, dolls and accessories, and even specialized items like Purim boxes and baskets. This variety ensures that every customer, whether looking for baby toys or outdoor play items, can find something to spark joy and creativity.

What makes this company a valuable addition to our directory is its commitment to offering better toys and better brands, creating a one-stop shop for all toy enthusiasts. With a focus on quality and a user-friendly shopping experience, it caters to a wide audience, including those seeking costumes, school supplies, and unique seasonal collections. The store’s dedication to customer satisfaction is evident in its convenient features like shipping and returns, gift certificates, and an accessible online platform, making it a go-to destination for toy shopping.

(718)3724327

6. Carter's

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

2111 86th St, 11214.0, Brooklyn

Children's clothing store
Baby clothing store
Baby store
Children's store
Clothing store
Fashion accessories store
Shoe store

Why we chose them

Carter’s is a leading destination for children’s apparel, offering a wide range of clothing and accessories for babies, toddlers, and kids. Known for its bright and basic styles, the store provides an extensive selection of clothing sizes from preemie to 14. Shoppers can find everything from pajamas and outerwear to dresses and shoes, ensuring that their little ones are stylishly outfitted for any occasion. Additionally, the store features well-loved brands like OshKosh B’gosh and Skip Hop, making it a one-stop shop for trusted quality and value.

This Brooklyn location stands out with its convenient shopping options, including online purchase with in-store or curbside pickup, making it easy for busy parents to get what they need. With services encompassing a children’s clothing store, baby clothing store, and shoe store, it caters to a variety of customer needs. The store also offers a fun play area, enhancing the shopping experience for families. Whether preparing for school, sleep, or play, this store ensures that every child is cute and comfy, underscoring its reputation as a reliable choice for everyday kids’ outfits.

(718)4999884

7. Brooklyn Superhero Supply Co

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ 4,4/5

372 5th Ave, 11215.0, Brooklyn

Non
profit organization
Charity
Collectibles store
Costume store
Toy store

Why we chose them

Brooklyn Superhero Supply Co. is a unique nonprofit organization that offers an imaginative array of superhero novelties, perfect for those aspiring to become their own heroes. The store specializes in selling a variety of superhero-themed products, such as capes, masks, gadgets, and even superpowers, catering to both children and adults. In addition to these fantastical items, the store is a treasure trove for literary enthusiasts, featuring publications from young authors associated with 826NYC. Hidden within the store is a secret door leading to a mysterious library, adding an element of adventure for visitors.

All proceeds from this engaging collectibles, costume, and toy store directly support 826NYC, a nonprofit that encourages creative writing and exploration of endless possibilities for young minds. The store not only provides unique gifts and toys but also serves as a charity hub, offering customers the option to donate to 826NYC with every purchase. Known for its whimsical and community-focused approach, this organization captures the spirit of creativity and empowerment, making it a standout addition to our directory.